JAMES MADISON QUOTE - 1822

"A popular government without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy; or, perhaps both. Knowledge will forever govern ignorance; and a people who mean to be their own governors must arm themselves with the power knowledge gives."

SCOTTSBORO WEATHER - SUN & MOON RISE

Tuesday, July 23, 2019

Scottsboro, Alabama - July 22, 2019 - IS THE JACKSON COUNTY COURTHOUSE SAFE? - Jackson County Commission Work Session and Regular Meeting - Structural Stability of the Jackson County Courthouse

Jackson County Courthouse, south side (photo by G. Morgan)

Agenda and meeting video below this segment on Jackson County Courthouse structural instability.

 Is the Jackson County Courthouse safe?
After 6 months and a geotechnical engineers report recommending IMMEDIATE tasks, corrective actions, and the acquisition of a structural engineer to further investigate the areas of visible structural deficiencies; there is no plan and there is no structural engineers report regarding the Jackson County Courthouse structural deficiencies noted and listed by Amiri Geotechnical Engineering Inc. provided to the Jackson County Commission (in PDF form). 
 
Northwest side records storage area in basement wall cracking extends up to the hard ceiling structure where separation of ceiling and wall is evident. (All video and photos above and below are by G. Morgan.)

Ground subsidence, collapse, is causing structural damage to the walls and floors as seen in this photo of the north public restroom which is now closed due to unstable walls and tiles.

Floor subsidence, note the depth of floor movement, 2 inches as demonstrated by the gap in the panel against the outer wall. Approximately 25-30 feet from this location is the courthouse incoming natural gas line.

Unstable structural footings and soils beneath the basement floor slab on the northwest corner have resulted in the load bearing wall to collapse the floor structure by 2-3 inches. The footing structure and soil are not supporting the building weight in this area, or is there a sinkhole developing? The engineers report states testing must be accomplished, nothing has been accomplished per the engineers recommendations. If there has been further testing it has been kept secret, just as the geotech engineers report was kept secret until questions were asked about the closing of the northwest public restroom due to structural instability by this citizen journalist.

Southside entry, wheelchair ramp. The original concrete slab has collapsed approximately 4 inches exposing this space between the original concrete slab and the newer wheelchair ramp.


1912 structure wall separation demonstrated in the 2 above photos. This is the Circuit Court's record storage area immediately south of the northwest corner structural problems. 

January 2019 a Geotechnical Engineer Report was provided to the Jackson County Commission on January 7 and January 9, 2019, a PDF of this report was acquired via a public records request last week. The critical summary of this report states - "Amiri Geotechnical Engineering Inc., Huntsville, Alabama: ". . .  it appears that storm water line failure which had resulted in loss of soil in the sewer lines may have resulted in ground loss under the footings and subsequently foundations subsided. However, other possibilities such as sinkhole development or failure of old underground structures, or other causes cannot be ruled out. Therefore, we recommend that a subsurface exploration program be conducted in the area immediately outside of northwestern end of the building to evaluate the subsurface conditions. We also recommend the following:"
"1. In order to reduce the possibility of further undermining of the same footings as well as other footings and floor slabs, we recommend that the existing sewer lines be tested to determine if there are any broken lines/failed lines that allow soil loss into the storm or sanitary sewer lines. Any sewer line failure should be repaired as soon as possible.
2. Retain a contractor to underpin the affected area. Underpinning may be conducted utilizing Helical Anchors or mini-piles. This should also be done as soon as possible to prevent further damage to the building.
3. We recommend that a Structural Engineer evaluate the integrity of this portion of the building as well as other portions which require structural repairs."

Within the email the engineering firm sent the commission back in January the following statement was noted:   Quote: " Please note that recommendations for immediate actions are presented in the report." More than 6 months later there have been no immediate actions taken regarding either a structured plan or a comprehensive structural engineers report. There were no blueprints, structural reports, or design reports, including historical well locations surrounding the courthouse supplied to the engineer as indicated in the report.

Courtroom 1, floor subsidence and cracking evident. Both entrances to courtroom one demonstrate floor cracking and a drop in the floor structure at the entrance to the courtroom. This area is part of the 1955-56 addition. There are other areas of wall cracking evident in this area.

Courtroom 2, uneven floor structure, appears to be areas of falling and/or collapse in this hallway entrance to courtroom 2. There are other areas of cracking of the floor structure evident in the courtroom 2 area, 1965-66 addition.

Video of courthouse structure instability


AGENDA JACKSON COUNTY COMMISSION, WORK SESSION AND REGULAR SESSION

VIDEOS OF MEETING

Citizen Presentations



Work Session and Regular Session  Video

No comments: